The biggest critique of Basic Structure doctrine from its inception has been it being shrouded in confusion, vagueness and a formulation which is loose and not precise. Critically examine. (10 marks)
Approach: Introduce by mentioning what basic structure is and its origin. Then, discuss confusion,
vagueness, and loose formulation in basic structure doctrine in form of lack of definition, being open to
interpretations etc. Present counter-arguments in form of evolution of basic structure list, lack of watertight
separation in constitution etc. Conclude with basic structure’s role in strengthening democratic
principle through various related judgements.
