DEC 10 – PM IAS Editorial Analysis

Editorial 1: The Goldilocks Moment, Carefully Calibrated (The Hindu)

• Core Topic: The implications of the Reserve Bank of India’s (RBI) recent Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) decisions, specifically the repo rate cut and the projection of strong growth amid subdued inflation.
• Syllabus Relevance: GS-III: Indian Economy; Monetary Policy; Financial stability.

Analysis and Argument

• The Rare Window: The editorial characterizes the current macroeconomic scenario as a “Goldilocks moment”—a rare period where India is witnessing strong growth (GDP projected at 7.3% for FY26) coupled with exceptionally low inflation (CPI revised down to 2.0%). This created the policy space for a rate cut.
• Rationale for Rate Cut: The 25 basis point reduction in the repo rate signals the RBI’s shift from a strict inflation-control mode to a growth-supportive stance. Cheaper credit is intended to boost private consumption, especially in housing and auto sales, and encourage long-delayed corporate capital expenditure (capex).
• Prudent Liquidity Management: A key area highlighted is the RBI’s use of unconventional liquidity tools. The announcement of the ₹1 trillion Open Market Operation (OMO) purchase and the $5 billion USD/INR buy-sell swap demonstrates a proactive attempt to inject durable liquidity and manage currency volatility simultaneously.
• The Caveats: The editorial cautions that the inflation figure is heavily influenced by a sharp correction in food prices, which are volatile due to weather events. Furthermore, external headwinds (global trade slowdown, high oil prices) remain a risk to export earnings and long-term price stability. The RBI must maintain a vigil on core inflation.

Impact and Way Forward (Editorial View)

1. Transmission: Commercial banks must swiftly pass on the rate cut benefit to borrowers to maximize the policy’s impact on the real economy.
2. Liquidity Targeting: The RBI’s use of OMOs is smarter than blunt rate changes; it should continue to use such targeted measures to keep the weighted average call rate aligned with the policy rate.
3. Fiscal Coordination: The rate cut provides the Fiscal Authority (Government) an opportunity to accelerate capital expenditure without crowding out private investment, ensuring the growth momentum is sustained.

---

Editorial 2: The Unhealthy Plate (Indian Express)

• Core Topic: An analysis of the Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES) data showing a shift in Indian diets toward low-quality carbohydrates and the resulting obesity/metabolic disease epidemic.
• Syllabus Relevance: GS-II: Issues relating to development and management of health; GS-III: Food security.

Analysis and Argument

• The Nutritional Paradox: Despite rising real per capita incomes and a decline in expenditure on cereals, the quantities consumed—particularly of refined cereals and sugar—remain high. The editorial cites the ICMR-INDIAB study showing that 62% of total energy in Indian diets comes from low-quality carbohydrates. This shift, driven by the cheapness and convenience of processed foods, is the leading cause of India’s growing metabolic disease burden (diabetes, hypertension).
• Policy Blind Spots: The focus of previous policy has been on food security (caloric availability) rather than nutrition security (quality of intake). While expenditures on protein and fruits have risen, they are still insufficient to compensate for the dominance of unhealthy carbs.
• The Affordability Crisis: The editorial points out that “being unhealthy is easier and cheaper” in India. Food companies are heavily invested in making affordable, culturally appropriate, but unhealthy products (like sugary snacks), making it difficult for citizens, especially the urban poor, to choose nutritious diets.

Policy Recommendations (Editorial View)

1. Taxation and Subsidies: Implement a ‘fat tax’ or ‘sugar tax’ on Ultra-Processed Foods (UPFs) and divert the revenue to subsidize the cultivation and sale of fruits, vegetables, and protein-rich pulses.
2. Public Procurement: Revamp public schemes like the Mid-Day Meal Scheme to prioritize protein and micronutrient density over mere caloric input.
3. Regulatory Scrutiny: The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) must enforce stringent regulations on labeling, mandatory warning signs on high-fat/sugar/salt foods, and curb misleading advertisements.
4. Whole-of-Society Engagement: Requires coordinated efforts from the Health Ministry, Agriculture Ministry, and the private sector to promote affordable, culturally aligned healthy alternatives.

Conclusion

The editorial concludes that India has successfully moved from a famine-hit nation to a major food exporter, but the final mile—achieving true nutrition security—requires a deliberate, policy-led intervention to change the composition of the average Indian’s plate.